question
For a beginner choosing their first PLC system between Siemens, Mitsubishi, and Allen-Bradley for a small manufacturing setup, what specific technical and operational factors beyond just price should determine the final selection?
answer
question
GregoryColeman
2025-11-26
answer
Hey there! As someone just starting out with PLCs for your small manufacturing setup, I totally get why you're looking beyond just price. Here are the key factors that should really guide your decision:
First up is programming ease - Allen-Bradley's Studio 5000 is often considered the most intuitive for beginners with a moderate learning curve (40-80 hours), while Siemens TIA Portal has a steeper learning curve (60-120 hours) but offers comprehensive features once you get the hang of it.
Software costs and availability matter too - Siemens software can run €8,000-€20,000 while Allen-Bradley is around $12,000-$15,000. But also consider if you can easily access training materials and community support for your chosen platform.
Think about your specific manufacturing needs: Allen-Bradley excels in discrete manufacturing and motion control, while Siemens is stronger in process industries. Mitsubishi often fits well in smaller, cost-sensitive applications.
Don't forget local support availability - Allen-Bradley dominates in North America, while Siemens has stronger global support. Check what technical support and training resources are accessible in your area.
Finally, consider future scalability - will this system grow with your business? Some platforms are easier to expand than others. For a beginner, I'd lean toward the system with the best local support and most intuitive programming environment that matches your specific manufacturing processes.
Quickly browse the latest questions and answers
Hey there! As a purchasing manager dealing with this '2026 automation squeeze,' I'm definitel...
check the detailsHey there! As someone dealing with legacy systems, I totally get the 'zombie parts' headache - those ...
check the detailsGreat question! I totally understand the challenge of wanting to modernize without breaking the bank on a full system...
check the detailsHey there! That's a really smart question - it's easy to get excited about the 24/7 production potent...
check the detailsHey team, I'm dealing with some real headaches trying to keep our 20-year-old PLCs and drives running. The ma...
check the detailsHey team, I'm facing a real dilemma with our aging automation equipment. We've got servo motors and d...
check the detailsHey there! Dealing with aging automation equipment while waiting months for replacement parts is a real challenge we ...
check the detailsHey there! I'm curious about lights-out factories too - it's fascinating how these fully automated fa...
check the detailsHey there! That's a really insightful question about lights-out manufacturing. You're right to look b...
check the detailsHey there! I'm dealing with some frustrating intermittent positioning errors in our servo motors, and the sta...
check the details