question
As a beginner staring at Siemens S7-1500 vs Mitsubishi FX5U vs Allen-Bradley CompactLogix, what are the REAL hidden costs beyond the price tag that nobody tells you about until you're 6 months into implementation?
answer
question
StevenAdams
2025-12-11
answer
Great question! As someone who's been there, let me tell you about the hidden costs that hit you months into implementation when you're already committed:
1. Software Licensing Bombshell: The PLC hardware is just the tip of the iceberg. Siemens TIA Portal can cost $495-$5,000+ depending on features. Allen-Bradley Studio 5000 runs about $1,052 USD/year for the Lite edition. Mitsubishi GX Works3 is $1,000-$5,000 but you might need multiple seats.
2. Training Time Sink: Siemens has a steeper learning curve - expect 2-3 months to get comfortable. Allen-Bradley is more beginner-friendly but still needs serious training. Mitsubishi documentation can be sparse, so you'll spend hours figuring things out.
3. Support & Maintenance Fees: Siemens charges for tech support after warranty. Allen-Bradley's Rockwell Automation support isn't cheap. Mitsubishi's support quality varies by region - you might need third-party help.
4. Ecosystem Lock-in: Once you choose Siemens, you're buying Siemens everything - HMIs, drives, networks. Allen-Bradley's ecosystem is expensive but integrated. Mitsubishi has cheaper add-ons but less seamless integration.
5. Downtime During Learning: Your first few projects will take 2-3x longer than expected. That's lost production time or delayed deliveries that nobody budgets for.
6. Certification Costs: Official Siemens training runs $1,500-$3,000 per course. Allen-Bradley certifications aren't cheap either. These add up fast when training a team.
The real kicker? You often don't realize these costs until you're months in and can't switch platforms without starting over. My advice: Budget 2-3x the hardware cost for the complete ecosystem, and don't underestimate the learning curve time!
Quickly browse the latest questions and answers
Hey there, I know that 2 AM production line shutdown feeling all too well! When you're staring at that red SF...
check the detailsHey there, fellow night-shift warrior! I've been in that exact 2 AM panic situation more times than I'...
check the detailsI feel your frustration! Dealing with recurring PLC communication errors while management just wants quick fixes is i...
check the detailsHey there! Great question - this is exactly the kind of practical troubleshooting skill that separates experienced te...
check the detailsHey there, I feel your pain! Staring at a cryptic 'Fault 0xE3' on an aging Siemens S7-300 at 2 AM wit...
check the detailsHey there! When that dreaded PLC communication failure hits during peak production, I know every second counts. Here&...
check the detailsOh no, the PLC communication just dropped during our busiest production run! I need to act fast but carefully. First,...
check the detailsOh man, I know that sinking feeling when the PLC communication drops during peak production! Here's my go-to ...
check the detailsHey there! I can feel your stress - staring at a mysterious PLC error code while the production line is hemorrhaging ...
check the detailsHey, I totally get that pressure cooker situation! When you're staring at those blinking red lights at 2 AM w...
check the details